SCOTUS Leaves California Implicit Bias Mandate Intact: A Warning for Michigan Healthcare Professionals
The Supreme Court's denial of review in Khatibi v. Yip leaves in place a Ninth Circuit ruling treating compelled “implicit bias” content in private medical education as government speech. Michigan’s own mandatory training requirement for healthcare licensees raises parallel First Amendment concerns.
The U.S. Supreme Court’s decision on November 16, 2026, to deny review in Khatibi v. Yip is more than a California story. It is a quiet but significant signal about how far states may go in dictating the content of professional education without meaningful First Amendment scrutiny. For physicians, nurses, physician assistants, and other healthcare professionals in Michigan – and especially those practicing in Washtenaw County – the ruling arrives against the backdrop of an existing statewide mandate that requires them to complete specific “implicit bias” training as a condition of keeping their licenses.
What the Supreme Court Left Standing
In Khatibi, California requires private instructors who teach continuing medical education (CME) courses – courses physicians must complete to maintain licensure – to include curriculum on implicit bias and its alleged effects on healthcare outcomes. Dr. Azadeh Khatibi and the organization Do No Harm challenged the requirement as compelled speech. The Ninth Circuit rejected the challenge, holding that the breadth of California’s regulation of CME transforms the privately taught courses into “government speech”. Under that doctrine, the state may dictate content without First Amendment review.
The Supreme Court denied the petition for certiorari. Justice Gorsuch would have granted review. Justice Thomas, joined by Justice Alito, dissented. Thomas argued that the Ninth Circuit fundamentally misunderstood both the Court’s precedents and the Constitution. Heavy regulation of a profession, he wrote, does not convert private speech into government speech. “First Amendment protections do not give way simply because a State heavily regulates speech.” A state “cannot regulate its way out of First Amendment scrutiny.”
Thomas emphasized a narrower understanding of the government-speech doctrine: the government is speaking only when it is engaged in the purposeful communication of its own message by a person acting within the scope of authority to speak for the government. Compelling private instructors to convey the state’s preferred message on a contested topic does not meet that standard. He warned that the doctrine must not become “a cover for censorship” or a cloak for compelled speech, and that the Ninth Circuit’s logic could allow states to force private speakers in regulated fields to promote official viewpoints on subjects such as abortion or gender-affirming care without real constitutional review.
Michigan’s Parallel Mandate
Michigan has its own version of this approach. Under Michigan Administrative Code Rule R 338.7004, administered by the Department of Licensing and Regulatory Affairs (LARA), nearly every profession licensed or registered under the Public Health Code must complete implicit bias training. Veterinary medicine is the main exception.
- New applicants must complete at least 2 hours within the five years preceding licensure
- Renewing licensees must complete 1 hour for each year of their license cycle (for fully licensed physicians on a typical three-year cycle, that means 3 hours every renewal)
The content is not left entirely open. Training must address implicit bias, equitable access, strategies to reduce disparities, the historical basis and present consequences of bias, and current research. It must include strategies to reduce disparities and the administration of pre- and post-test assessments. Acceptable sponsors are broadly defined, but the subject matter is prescribed by the state as a condition of practicing.
This is not identical to California’s rule, which focuses on the content of every CME course taught by private instructors. Michigan’s rule operates primarily as a condition on the licensee rather than a mandate on every course. However, the constitutional concerns overlap substantially: both involve the state requiring individuals in a heavily regulated profession to engage with specific, contested content in order to maintain the legal right to work.
Local Context in Washtenaw County
Washtenaw County is home to a dense concentration of physicians, researchers, and healthcare professionals affiliated with the University of Michigan and other institutions. These professionals are subject to the statewide LARA rule. In 2024, the Washtenaw County Delegation to the Michigan State Medical Society introduced a resolution urging that the implicit bias training requirement be limited to a one-time obligation rather than recurring with every renewal cycle (on the basis that the “research” does not change from year to year). The resolution was not approved. The Michigan State Medical Society has previously expressed opposition to compulsory specific content in mandated continuing medical education.
The combination of a statewide licensing condition and unsuccessful local efforts to narrow it means the issue is not abstract for Washtenaw professionals. Physicians and other clinicians who question the scientific basis, ideological framing, or necessity of particular implicit bias content still face the requirement as the price of licensure.
Michigan’s rule is harder to challenge than California’s. It requires licensees to complete hours of training rather than forcing private instructors to insert specific content into every course. Courts have been more deferential to educational licensing conditions than to pure compelled-speech mandates. In the near term, the more realistic path is administrative: the requirement is a LARA rule, not a statute, so a future administration can amend or rescind it without the legislature.
The Constitutional Stakes
Professional licensing has long been accepted as a legitimate exercise of state power. States may require competence, ethics training, and knowledge of relevant law. The question raised by Khatibi and by Michigan’s rule is whether that power extends to compelling engagement with particular viewpoints on contested social and scientific questions, and whether courts will treat such requirements as largely immune from First Amendment review once a field is heavily regulated.
Thomas’ dissent highlights the risk that the government-speech doctrine, or related professional-regulation doctrines, can be expanded until regulated private speech is recharacterized as the state’s own. If that approach takes hold more broadly, challenges to Michigan’s rule – or to similar mandates in other states – become harder. Licensees who object on free-speech grounds may be told that the training is simply a condition of a privilege the state may define, or that the content is effectively government speech because the state controls licensure.
That framing has consequences beyond any single training topic. Once the principle is accepted that extensive regulation of a profession allows the state to dictate educational content with minimal constitutional scrutiny, the boundary between legitimate professional standards and compelled ideological conformity becomes difficult to police. Future requirements could address other contested subjects while receiving the same deferential treatment.
A Matter for Public Attention
The Supreme Court’s denial of review does not affirm the Ninth Circuit’s reasoning; it simply leaves the decision in place for now. It does, however, mean that the expansive view of government speech in this context remains uncorrected at the highest level.
Michigan professionals and policymakers should take notice.
In his dissent, Justice Thomas made clear that heavy regulation of a profession does not allow a state to compel speech free from First Amendment scrutiny. Whether one supports the goals of the training or questions its premises, the mechanism – using the power of licensure to require engagement with specific content – deserves scrutiny under those principles.

